The CMA Awards Promised Surprises And All We Got Was A Horrifying Brooks and Dunn Tribute

Share
The CMA Awards Promised Surprises And All We Got Was A Horrifying Brooks and Dunn Tribute

Ok, so I'm exaggerating slightly. The much ballyhooed 60th annual CMA Awards extravaganza was not without its highlights, mostly performance-wise (we even got Megan Moroney's strongest on-air singing to date…granted, of her worst song…). But considering the major anniversary and the monumental country music news of the year — unprecedented domination by "Choosin' Texas" and the passing of arguably the genre's biggest star, Dolly Parton — the show felt decidedly business as usual, right down to the overall humorlessness and perplexing, momentum-killing collaborations. On Ella Langley's crowning night, why oh why were we subjected to Mumford & Sons?!

Instead of getting a true one-off celebration, viewers were reminded that even more so than most awards shows, the CMAs are a critical cog in their industry's machinery — a place for politicking, for everyone to perform whatever single is going to radio currently, and favors to be manifested for whatever intersection of major label/management/agency/radio is most critical to appease at any given moment (the only possible explanation, I think, for Chris Stapleton to waste his talents working with the aforementioned Mumford & Sons). The ceremony is a list of boxes getting checked, from new country HOFers getting recognized to the requisite namechecking of The Troops (in a characteristically tacky segment sponsored by Chevrolet…it used to be Crown Royal, lol). Even with so much material, then, we had to trudge through our collective country music obligations; the good stuff — the sincerity — appeared only occasionally.

The show kicked off with its Dolly tribute — Lainey and Vince Gill singing "I Will Always Love You" with appropriate reverence and fluency. Granted, I fully expected that to be kind of a teaser tribute, with something meatier later…but no, too many boxes to check. Then we had Brad Paisley joining Lainey for the opening monologue to reprise the musical parodies he used to do annually with Carrie Underwood. They started off with a pretty pointed critique of data centers (to the tune of "I was born a data miner's daughter" — kudos to Brad for staying the course) but otherwise were toothless. They kept namechecking stars in the audience but about jokes that were completely made up, rather than actual roasts — save Taylor Swift, who was subject to a jibe about her MSG wedding (only after Lainey Wilson did a self-deprecating bit about being a blonde singer who married a football player this year). The best joke was probably about AI: "There was no artificial intelligence of any kind used in the creation of this monologue…in fact, there was no intelligence of any kind…a tradition started by Luke and Peyton." That's a little backwoods hokum we can get behind! (The only other whiff of politics came much later when Vince Gill riffed that he had been "colluding with the Russians for years" by way of explanation for all his CMA awards. Blue wave hits Nashville???)

The primary recognition of the 60th anniversary seemed to be that Lainey was compelled to appear alongside a bunch of former hosts rather than solo — which…fine, but since they were all men felt a little patronizing. We got like three too many mentions of the whole Kershaw Kerfuffle, starting early on. As Marissa wrote for RS, it's telling that the CMA will bend over backwards to soothe the hurt feelings of an old white guy but is stubbornly resistant to critique of its systematic lack of support for Black artists; on the red carpet, for example, country-rap icons Nappy Roots were asked to comment on the fact that they "haven't always been the face of country music" (JESUS h christ). "We've been here the whole time," replied Skinny DeVille (bless him). 

The Ella Langley of it all — her six wins were the most of any performer in a single year — started early with Single Of The Year for "Choosin' Texas." "Y'all, it's a country song," Miranda Lambert said during her acceptance speech — and indeed it is. The association seemed very ready to reward a song that is commercially massive as well as Traditionally Country Signaling (Langley even shouted out session guitarist Tom Bukovac), much in the same way that they can never resist the chance to give Chris Stapleton a statue. He won Male Vocalist of the Year for the zillionth time, and accepted almost begrudgingly. "I'm always rooting for everyone else in this category," he said in his speech. Because radio, she did a kind of lackluster rendition of the kind of snoozy single "Lovin' Life Again" instead of the song on everyone's minds and ears. 

She dutifully brought Miranda up for every win (as is just), and Miranda seemed resigned and more or less content with her new role as elder stateswoman/sidekick (her hyped performance with Kacey was a little silted; it was cool that Crisco got some primetime shine, but again not a super strong sell for the music, unfortunately). In a year when a woman was running the show as a host and a woman was winning almost all the awards, there was very little recognition of how massive a moment it is for women in country music right now — yet another missed opportunity. Lainey's performance of her new single "Just A Woman," though, might have been the very best of the night. She is just rock solid, always. (Notice I'm not saying anything about Taylor, because if you don't have anything nice to say etc. Bringing MAGA-leaning Brittany Mahomes as a date is…a choice though.)

No, in a year when Gen Z country music women are making pop music waves, we got lots and lots and lots of…Brooks & Dunn. And we love Brooks & Dunn! But when the voiceover is saying "This is Brooks & Dunn's 17th win for vocal duo of the year, breaking the record they set last year" — well, we're kind of beyond parody (Muscadine Bloodline was robbed!). The tribute that went along with their lifetime achievement award was both the most ambitious and the worst part of the show. It was inexplicably rock (because Brooks & Dunn are best known for…shredding?) with Halestorm (very cursed that I now know who they are) doing a screamy "Boot Scootin' Boogie" and Hardy torturing everyone with an aughts-post-grunge take on "Hillbilly Deluxe"...the reaction shots to Ronnie and Kix and wives were everything, at least. They were totally perplexed, as were we all; Brooks & Dunn covers are a staple of every bar in America, and yet somehow on the biggest stage we get the worst ones that have ever been conceived of. Nightmare! They recovered from the auditory onslaught in time to share very sweet acceptance speeches ("My wife was asking, 'Where's the steel guitar?'" Ronnie quipped, bless him), with lots of endearing, meandering discussion of the outlaws. "Those names will never be my peers, they're our heroes," Kix Brooks concluded. It was nice. 

After all that, Ella trooped back up onstage to claim Female Vocalist of the Year and Entertainer of the Year, at which point Lainey brought out a bedazzled broom (Langley must not be a sports fan, because she seemed confused about the "sweep" lol). With that, it's officially "Will 'All I Want For Christmas Is You' Finally Break The 'Choosin' Texas' Streak" season — buckle up for many more takes TK.